Your next step
What you’ll learn
- Separate evidence from assumptions.
- Match the strength of a conclusion to the evidence.
- Explain why an unsupported answer goes too far.
Step 01
Build the smallest supported conclusion
Identify what the passage directly establishes before looking at the answer choices. Then ask what follows from those facts without adding a new cause, motive, or general rule.
If an experiment reports a result under one set of conditions, the evidence may justify a conclusion about those conditions. It does not automatically establish the same result for every environment, species, or time period.
Worked example
In a greenhouse trial, seedlings exposed to a particular lamp grew taller than seedlings receiving the same amount of water under ordinary lamps. What does the result support?
- The measured difference concerns seedling height under the trial conditions.
- The passage supports an association between the tested lighting condition and greater height in this trial.
- It does not establish greater fruit yield, longer life, or the same effect in every plant species.
The tested lighting condition may promote taller growth under the conditions of the trial.
Step 02
Check the strength of each word
Words such as “all,” “always,” “only,” and “must” make a claim stronger. They are not automatically wrong, but they need correspondingly strong evidence. A passage describing some examples rarely proves a universal rule.
A cautious expression such as “suggests” does not rescue an otherwise unsupported idea. The answer still needs a clear connection to the actual information in the passage.
- Quantity: does the text concern one example, several cases, or an entire population?
- Cause: does it establish a reason or merely report a pattern?
- Comparison: are the same outcome and conditions being compared?
- Scope: has the answer introduced a different place, period, or subject?
Step 03
Explain the unsupported step
When eliminating a choice, name the extra assumption it needs. This is more reliable than saying that it “sounds wrong.” A distractor may borrow the passage’s vocabulary while changing the relationship between its ideas.
After choosing an answer, point to the evidence that supports every important part of it. If one clause is supported but another introduces a new claim, the whole choice may fail.
Worked example
A museum’s surviving shipping records list several ceramic objects sent overseas in 1890. Which inference is safer: “Some ceramics were shipped overseas in 1890” or “Ceramics were the museum’s most valuable objects”?
- The records directly support the existence of the shipments.
- They contain no information about relative monetary value. The second statement needs an additional assumption.
Some ceramics were shipped overseas in 1890.
Put it to work
Try it yourself
Work out your answer before opening the solution.
Three surviving letters mention a writer’s interest in astronomy. Do they show that astronomy was the writer’s only interest?
Show solution
- The letters establish an interest in astronomy, but they do not rule out other interests.
No. The claim of an exclusive interest is unsupported.
A material expanded when heated in a laboratory test. Does this prove that all materials expand at every temperature?
Show solution
- The evidence concerns one material and the temperatures tested. The proposed conclusion generalizes beyond both limits.
No. A conclusion must stay within the evidence’s scope.
Official course and exam information
The explanations and examples above are ScorePeak learning resources. For official exam structure and course scope, use these references.
From understanding to practice
Make the next session count.
Apply what you’ve learned in the ScorePeak practice workspace. Interactive tests, assignments, and saved results require an approved account.